Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

Discover Tony's Pizza in Elizabeth City, NC, where you can enjoy authentic NY-style pizza, garlic knots, stromboli, wings, and classic Italian dishes like spaghetti, sub sandwiches, calzones, and steak. Call +1 252-338-5757 for delicious food and friendly service!

Welcome to Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

Experience the finest dining

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City offers a warm atmosphere full of flavors and community spirit. Located at 100 Alexander Ct in Elizabeth City, NC, this beloved pizzeria serves delicious Italian cuisine for every palate. From mouthwatering garlic knots to cheesy calzones and famously large slices of New York-style pizza, Tony’s delivers on taste and variety. With a bustling crowd during peak hours, especially on Fridays at 6 PM, this bustling kitchen feels alive with energy.

Join folks from all around as they indulge in a range of dishes, from hearty spaghetti to flavorful wings, all crafted with care. Whether you're dining in or taking out, the smells wafting through the air will draw you in. A visit here is more than just a meal; it's a slice of the community.

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City highlights a diverse menu that caters to various appetites. Appetizers like mozzarella sticks and fried cheese ravioli set the tone for the meal, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. The variety of salads, including the Italian and grilled chicken salads, offer fresh and crisp options for those seeking lighter fare. Tony's pasta selection shines, featuring stuffed shells and fettuccini Alfredo that delight every pasta lover. The chicken and veal dishes provide a taste of tender, flavorful proteins, while seafood options such as linguini with clams add a unique touch.

Don't miss the signature hoagies, packed with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The average price per dish of $10.69 makes indulging in these favorites approachable, ensuring everyone can enjoy a hearty meal.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

100 Alexander Ct, Elizabeth City, NC 27909, United States

Phone

+1 252-338-5757

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City
Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City has become a cornerstone of the local dining scene since opening its doors. The rich aromas from the kitchen and the cheerful atmosphere welcome diners as they step inside. The establishment thrives on a commitment to quality ingredients and authentic recipes, ensuring that each dish reflects the heart of Italian cuisine. Popular dishes like the chicken parmesan and steak strombolis nourish both the body and soul, embodying the spirit of comfort food.

Among the local favorites, garlic knots deserve a special mention for their flavor, often starting conversations about family recipes and sharing traditions. Guests often rave about how each visit feels like a gathering with friends, creating an unmatched sense of community. The staff’s dedication amplifies this atmosphere, as they know regulars by name and deliver service with a friendly smile.

Tony’s not only excels in food but also creates experiences. It’s common to see families celebrating special moments or friends gathering to catch up over a delicious meal, making it a social hub as much as a dining destination. Tony's is a safe spot for pizza lovers, as each slice boasts standards of quality and flavor. The attention to detail in their offerings ensures that dining here feels like a cherished ritual for many.

Known for busy nights, particularly Fridays, it's a good idea to arrive early for a prime table or take advantage of off-peak hours during lunch for a quieter experience. Whether it’s a casual lunch or a cozy dinner with loved ones, Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City ensures satisfaction in every bite, making it a go-to spot in Elizabeth City.

Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City

The exterior of Tony's Pizza Elizabeth City is inviting, with traditional Italian touches that hint at the delicious offerings within. Located in a lively area, it features a warm, welcoming entrance that entices passersby. Inside, vibrant colors and casual seating create a homey vibe. The hustle and bustle during peak times adds excitement, yet the decor maintains comfort, allowing everyone to feel right at home. This combination of charm and energy draws in locals and visitors alike.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-7:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Saturday4-8:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

My old friends from high school met up at Tony's yesterday for lunch, and it turned into a surprise birthday party for me. We had a great time! The pizzas were terrific as always, and Stephanie couldn't have been a better server. She was very cordial and friendly and mixed well into our conversations at the table. Thank you Stephanie!

C
Charlie

Friendly staff and great pizza, whether sitting down to eat or carry out order. It's always fresh and tastes good.

m
michael b.

I order a pizza a carry out and it was very good. My first time eating at Tony's and I read 1 review and someone gave it a bad review and they must of had a bad night. I really liked my pizza and my wife and I will return. While I waited for the pizza to be cooked in the parking lot with plenty of parking spaces. It's the local favorite places too. Parking lot is packed. Nice restaurant.

A
Andrew J.

Great pizza, nice atmosphere, and friendly attentive service! Will definitely be back! Best pizza we've had in E City!

H
Heather M.

Good food good service except on refills on sora. Had Pepperoni extra cheese pizza . Not sure the extra cheese showed up. Will go back to try again

J
J W.

Born and raised in the tri-state ,NJ/NY. We have been on the hunt for true Italian food since we moved here, well Tony's is the place! We knew the second we walked in the true ambience of a Jersey restaurant! From the basket of warm Italian bread to the perfectly cooked pasta this place is it! We have been home sick for REAL Italian food, and we got our fix! We will definitely be back! PS Don't forget a authentic cannoli for dessert.

J
Julie W.